Cost and Yardage

Reupholstering vs Buying New Furniture: Which Makes Sense?

A decision guide for choosing between reupholstering and buying new, based on frame quality, like-for-like cost, sentimental value and the piece's size.

On this page
  1. Start with the frame
  2. Compare like for like
  3. Consider the piece’s value to you
  4. Consider size and layout
  5. Consider the environment
  6. Quick decision checklist
  7. Related guides

Reupholstering makes sense when the frame is sound and the piece is worth more to you than a comparable new one. Buying new often makes more sense when the frame is weak, the piece no longer fits your space, or a new piece of the same quality would cost about the same. Work through the checks below before you decide.

Start with the frame

The frame usually decides the question. Fabric and foam can be replaced, but a weak frame is expensive to fix and may not hold a new cover well.

Frames usually worth reupholstering:

Frames usually not worth reupholstering:

  • Particleboard or MDF
  • Frames held together mainly with staples
  • Thin, low-density foam on a piece whose frame is also weak

Frame test: lift one front corner about 6 inches. If the other front leg lifts too, the frame is rigid. If the piece twists, the frame is weak.

Compare like for like

Compare a reupholstery quote with a new piece of the same quality, not a budget substitute. Typical US ranges:

  • Sofa reupholstered, fabric included: about $1,500 to $4,000
  • New sofa: budget $300 to $800, mid-range $1,000 to $3,000, high-end $3,000 or more

A common rule of thumb is that reupholstering tends to pay off for pieces that would cost $2,000 to $3,000 or more to replace at the same quality. For the full cost comparison, see is reupholstering cheaper than buying new.

Consider the piece’s value to you

  • Antiques and collectibles: new upholstery can lower a piece’s collector value. Get an appraisal before you start.
  • Sentimental pieces: many people reupholster a family piece whatever the cost.
  • Custom fit: if the piece suits your body, your room or your habits in a way a new one won’t, that counts.

Consider size and layout

If you need a different size, shape or seating count, the existing frame may not give you that. Some upholsterers can make a piece larger, but buying new is often easier when the change is large.

Consider the environment

A 2018 US EPA estimate put discarded furniture and furnishings at about 12.1 million tons, with roughly 80 percent sent to landfill. Reupholstering keeps a sound frame in use, which is one reason people choose it.

Quick decision checklist

Reupholster when:

  • The frame is solid and passes the lift test.
  • The springs and foam can be repaired or replaced.
  • The piece is worth more to you than a like-for-like new one would cost.

Buy new when:

  • The frame is particleboard, MDF or held together with staples.
  • You need a different size or layout.
  • The piece is budget furniture, and the reupholstery quote is higher than the price of a new one.

If the problem is only the look, a slipcover or cushion recover may cost less than a full job. See when to reupholster furniture for the signs to check first.

The complete guide to cost and yardage

Upholstery Cost: Pricing Chart for Reupholstering Furniture
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →