Quick answer
Spraying gives the smoothest finish and reaches spindles, louvers, and carvings fastest. Brushing gives you more control, less overspray, and minimal setup, and it works with any paint. For small pieces, touch-ups, and indoor jobs with limited space, brushing is often the simpler choice. For detailed pieces where a smooth finish matters most, spraying is usually better, provided you can mask the area and ventilate well.
When spraying is the better choice
- Smooth finish. A sprayed coat is free of brush marks, especially in satin or gloss.
- Detail. Spray reaches spindles, molding, and tight corners without pooling paint.
- Speed on detailed work. Spraying can cover intricate pieces quickly, although masking takes time.
Spraying has trade-offs. You need to mask nearby surfaces, set up a drop cloth or spray booth, and ventilate well. It also wastes more paint through overspray. Aerosol cans usually work best when held about 10 to 16 inches from the surface, with light sweeping passes. Check the label for the exact distance. HVLP sprayers usually need latex or chalk paint thinned to the ratio the sprayer and paint maker recommend.
Aerosol is not cheaper for large pieces. A big project can take many cans.
When brushing is the better choice
- Control. A brush lets you place paint exactly where you want it.
- Less setup. Brushing needs little masking and produces little overspray.
- Any paint. Brushing works with virtually any paint type, which makes it flexible.
- Indoor work. Brushing latex paint avoids the solvent vapor that spray cans release, which makes it easier in a small room.
Brushing takes longer and can leave visible brush strokes if the paint does not level well. To brush latex, use a quality synthetic (nylon or polyester) brush. For oil-based paint, use a natural-bristle brush. Adding a paint conditioner such as Floetrol to latex can reduce brush marks, and self-leveling enamels also help.
Rollers as a middle ground
Foam or microfiber rollers work well on flat surfaces, such as tabletops and drawer fronts. A small foam roller can also smooth out brush marks after brushing.
Prep applies to both methods
- Clean the piece, then scuff-sand it with 120 to 220 grit.
- Prime glossy surfaces, and prime wood that tends to bleed through. Shellac-based primer blocks tannin bleed.
- Sand lightly with 220 to 320 grit between coats for a smooth finish.
Skipping primer causes adhesion and bleed-through problems with either method.
Coats and curing
Several thin coats beat one thick coat, whether you spray or brush. Latex paint dries to the touch in about an hour, but it can take two to four weeks to fully cure. Cure time varies by product, so check the label before you put the piece into heavy use.
Common misconceptions
- Spraying is not always faster. For one small piece, masking and cleanup can take longer than brushing.
- Brush marks come mostly from overworking the paint and from cheap brushes. They are not an inevitable result of brushing.
- Aerosol is not cheaper for big pieces. It often takes many cans.
Safety
- Spray only with good ventilation. Wear a respirator with organic vapor cartridges, plus eye protection.
- Wear a dust mask when sanding. If the piece may have older paint, test it for lead before you sand, especially in homes built before 1978.
Fabric and upholstered pieces
Upholstered furniture needs a different approach. Fabric paint soaks into the fibers, and painted fabric feels stiffer than the original. For sofas and other upholstered pieces, see our guide to fabric paint for sofas.